Jewelry stores in New York City are an intrinsic part of the city’s glitter and glam. Whether your luxury tastes veer toward contemporary jewels or vintage boutique finds, one problem you’ll likely encounter in New York City is that of overchoice—an overwhelming abundance of possibilities. Here are five elegant shops where you can begin your search for the perfect piece. The beautifully curated collections at these jewelry stores in New York take much of the guesswork out of shopping for fine jewelry.
The dramatic glass façade of Adornia is easy to spot on the tree-lined street in Nolita. Girlfriends Becca Aronson (a former fashion editor) and Moran Amir, who met at Wharton Business School, teamed up after graduation to create a wildly popular jewelry collection they’ve dubbed Downtown Diamonds, which is sold here and at other retailers. Whether it’s layered necklaces, stacked rings, or moon-shaped studs that catch your eye, the pieces in the striking black display cases all share a contemporary, edgy flair that’s perfect for gift-giving or keeping for yourself.
There are no crowds here. Walking into the Fred Leighton store on Madison Avenue feels more like visiting your family jeweler, although, inarguably, it’s one of the quintessential jewelry stores in New York City. The gray tones of the art deco-style store are the perfect foil for its collection of extraordinary bespoke jewels, many of which wind up being worn by royalty, CEOs, and celebrities on the red carpet. Vintage jewelry that dates back some 200 years is displayed alongside new designs that will one day become classics. If you’re daunted by the prices of the very high-end pieces for the seriously rich and famous, ask to see some of the more affordable “vintage-inspired” pieces.
The wait is over. Be sure to visit the totally revamped jewelry salon at Bergdorf Goodman. Noted architect Michael Neumann spearheaded this stunning redesign that evokes the glitz and glamour of the ’30s. The “store within a store” is almost like a sparkling jewelry box with its own entrance and window displays on 57th Street. The makeover separated the baubles from the bevy of other luxury wares sold by this legendary retailer which has been in business for 116 years.
When you’re finished gazing at the brilliant custom chandeliers, hexagonal display cases, and dazzling pearl gray wall and floor coverings, you’ll recognize all the iconic designer brand names. Bergdorf recently launched a new gemstone collection with Gemfields. The one-of-a-kind collection of rubies and emeralds by a group of top designers is ethically sourced.
Dover Street Market New York
This two-year-old NYC outpost of the international concept store Dover Street Market New York occupies an oversize but minimalist industrial space on Lexington Avenue. Drag yourself past the eye-catching collections of high-end clothes, of-the-moment fashion accessories, and avant-garde Japanese home goods to check out the spectacular collection of designer and vintage boutique items that defy tradition. In a unique partnership with Tiffany & Co., Dover Street is also carrying the venerable jeweler’s Out of Retirement™ collection—eight jewelry designs drawn from the Tiffany Archives. In another break with tradition, purchases from this collection are packaged in the traditional Tiffany-blue boxes, but with black ribbons instead of white ones.
Founded by third-generation jeweler Monica Udernomall Alwani, this contemporary shop with white interior walls and modern décor sits behind a navy blue awning in Gramercy Park. In addition to fine diamonds, Amaaya carries an exclusive collection of earrings, bracelets, necklaces, rings, and more from uber-popular designer brands. Moreover, you’ll be wowed by the personalized service.